Saving.Careers

Blogs

The job did not disappear. The proof did.3 min readWhat a portfolio proves that a CV cannot3 min readNobody is coming to save your career2 min readNinety days: what to build, and what to ignore2 min readThe reinvention nobody sees2 min readSee all

Rooms

← Rooms

The Ask

Open to the communityActive 3w ago

One situation, one specific request. Where you are, what you have tried, the one thing you need.

Join
Nikhil Sharma7w

How to ask here

The Ask works when the request is small enough to answer.

"Help me find a job" cannot be answered by anybody. "I have eleven years in supply chain, I am being pushed toward a role I do not want, and I need to know whether my experience means anything outside manufacturing" can be answered by three people before lunch.

So the format is:

Where you are. Two lines. Role, years, what changed. What you have tried. One line. It stops people repeating what did not work. The one thing you need. A review, an introduction, a straight answer, a reality check. One.

Then come back and tell us what happened. That is the part that makes this room worth the next person's time.

Go first - what is your one thing this week?

Nikhil SharmaDiscussion3w

Discussion

Tell me the last thing that actually got you an interview

Not what you think should work. What worked.

Most career advice is written by people who have never tested it and repeated by people who have never needed it. Meanwhile the real answers are sitting inside this room, unshared, because each person assumes their own story was luck.

So: the last time you got in front of somebody who could hire you — how did it actually happen? A referral. A cold mes

Nikhil SharmaDiscussion3w

Discussion

What are you being told you are too old or too new for?

Both ends of this room hear a version of the same sentence.

At one end: you do not have the experience, so we cannot give you the job that would give you the experience. At the other: you have too much experience, which gets called overqualified because the honest word is expensive.

Both are a way of saying no without saying why. Sometimes there is a real objection underneath and it can be answe

Nikhil Sharma3w

Tell me the last thing that actually got you an interview

Not what you think should work. What worked.

Most career advice is written by people who have never tested it and repeated by people who have never needed it. Meanwhile the real answers are sitting in this room, unshared, because each person assumes their own story was luck.

So: the last time you got in front of somebody who could hire you - how did it actually happen? A referral. A cold message that landed. Somebody who remembered you from four years ago. An application form, genuinely, because sometimes those do work and we have all stopped saying so.

One line is enough. If there is a pattern in the answers it will be more useful than anything I could write.

What worked for you?

Nikhil Sharma3w

What are you being told you are too old or too new for?

Both ends of this room hear a version of the same sentence.

At one end: you do not have experience, so we cannot give you the job that would give you experience. At the other: you have too much experience, which gets called overqualified because the honest word is expensive.

Both are a way of saying no without saying why. Sometimes there is a real objection underneath and it can be answered. Sometimes there is nothing underneath at all and you are polishing a rejection that was never about you.

Telling those apart alone is very hard. Telling them apart with three other people looking at it is not.

So put yours here. What is the door, what were the exact words, and what do you suspect is really behind it?

Nikhil Sharma3w

Where are you right now?

0 responses

That is the beginning. You have seen every one of the posts.

Saving.Careers

For the part of a career nobody plans for.

23Posts
5Rooms
Join Saving.Careers

Search Saving.Careers

Latest updates

Nikhil Sharmaposted an update · 3wNikhil Sharmaposted an update · 3wNikhil Sharmaposted an update · 3wNikhil Sharmaposted an update · 3wNikhil Sharmaposted an update · 3wThe feed